How To Compare Shingle Vs Metal Roofing

/, Metal, Metal Roofing, roofing, shingle/How To Compare Shingle Vs Metal Roofing

How To Compare Shingle Vs Metal Roofing

The roof acts as your home’s first line of defense against harsh weather elements. When selecting the right roofing for your home, two materials stand out; shingle and metal. However, the two have distinct features, benefits, and drawbacks you need to consider before you purchase.

Weighing all the advantages and disadvantages of each roofing material can be overwhelming.

This guide gives an honest comparison of everything you need to know about the two materials based on:

  • Durability
  • Lifespan
  • Aesthetic look
  • Energy efficiency
  • Cost
  • Length to install
  • Maintenace
  • Storms

Pros, Cons, and Features of Metal and Shingles Roofing

When choosing the right roof material for your home, you need to pick one securing your home from the harsh weather elements. It should insulate your home from the hot summer heat and the freezing winter cold.


Metal roofs will stand up to the harshest weather Mother Nature throws at it. As a result, most of these roofs get a 30-40 years warranty. In most cases, they outlast the warranties by lasting 40-70 years.

But just like any other material, they have a share of their weakness. Walking on metal roof improperly, hailstorm, and falling branches can easily dent your roof. 

Shingles have a unique set of weaknesses, like losing granules or the shingles getting torn off, shortening their overall lifespan. Therefore, shingle roofs get a shorter warranty depending on the manufacturer.


Lifespan is one of the key differences in determining whether a metal roof is better than asphalt shingles. Generally, a metal roofing lasts for up to 50 years before the first signs of deterioration start to show. Depending on the metal alloys used, sometimes a metal roof can even longer. 

Shingle roofs have a shorter lifespan of around 20 years, but with proper maintenance and repairs can last longer.

Aesthetic Look

Metals roofs come in a variety of colors and styles to choose from. They compliment any home, and they help to increase the curb appeal. 

Asphalt shingles are available in more colors than metal roofs. They’re also more popular in many homes across the country and are more likely to be consistent with other houses in your neighborhood. 

Energy Efficiency

The reflective metal roof surface lessens heat transfer to your home during summer. Besides, metal roof manufacturers nowadays produce highly emissive metal panels which efficiently release absorbed heat during high temperatures. 

Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, absorb the sun’s heat and transfer it to your home through the roof. This makes the cooling system in your home work more to keep your home cool. However, shingle roofing keeps your home warm during winter by using the heat absorbed from winter sunlight. 


The cost of metal roofing depends on the type of material you choose. It’s an expensive material to use for your roof.

Asphalt roofing is much cheaper, but the cost depends on what style of shingles you go with. Plus the overall quality of the shingles as well.

Length to Install

Metal roof installation requires precision and, hence, you need a professional contractor who is equipped and skilled at metal roof installation. How long it takes to install a metal roof depends on the prevailing weather and the size of the house. 

Shingles are easier to install and takes can usually be installed in one day. Similarly, the length of installation depends on the weather and size of the house. 


Both metal and asphalt shingles require a professional inspection at least once a year but twice is recommended. During these checkups, the roofer will inspect the roofing material to ensure it’s holding up, they’ll check for areas of damage, search for leaks, and more.

Storms, Fire, and Water Resistance

Metal roofing can be fortified with a coating to prevent rust. These roofs are also resistant to weather, fire, and harsh climatic conditions. However, metal roofs are prone to dents during hail storms, especially if you use the thinner varieties. 

Asphalt roofs have higher fire safety ratings. However, the standard varieties are susceptible to harsh weather and climate, such as hail and UV rays. When there is excess moisture, shingles can grow moss and algae. 

Different Types of Shingles Vs. Metal

Metal roofs are available in a variety of styles, depending on the metals and type of coating used. The most commonly used metals for roofing include zinc, titanium, aluminum, stainless steel, and copper. Steel is also used, but it requires special treatment to prevent rusting. 

Metal roofs have a glossy finish, low gloss, and are sometimes stone-coated to look like shingles. You can decide to choose stamped metal panels which imitate slate, asphalt, and wood shingles. 

Asphalt shingles are available in traditional and heavy architectural styles and have a limited color variation. 

So, Is a Metal Roof Better Than Asphalt Shingles?

To decide whether a metal roof is better than asphalt shingles depends on a multitude of factors like durability, cost of installation, maintenance, and aesthetics. At Wyoming Roofing, we strive to make your roof the best it can. Whether you’re looking for a new installation or a replacement, contact us today and we’ll be glad to help!

2020-06-22T06:15:13+00:00By |Blog, Metal, Metal Roofing, roofing, shingle|